CVSA Votes to Impose Out-of-Service Penalties for Truck Drivers with Limited English Proficiency

In a significant move aimed at enhancing road safety and compliance within the trucking industry, the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA) has voted to implement out-of-service penalties for truck drivers who demonstrate limited English proficiency. This decision underscores the CVSA's commitment to ensuring that all commercial drivers possess the necessary communication skills to understand critical safety regulations, navigate road conditions, and respond appropriately in emergency situations. With the growing diversity of the trucking workforce, the CVSA recognizes that language barriers can pose substantial risks, not only to the drivers themselves but also to other road users. The new penalties will serve as a pivotal measure to encourage drivers to improve their English language skills, thereby fostering a safer driving environment. As the trucking industry continues to evolve in response to globalization and demographic shifts, this policy is poised to spark discussion about the balance between accessibility and safety in commercial transportation. This article will delve into the implications of these penalties, the rationale behind their implementation, and the potential impact on both drivers and the broader trucking community.

CVSA Votes to Reinstate English Proficiency Violations as Out-of-Service Offense

On Thursday, the Board of Directors of the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance (CVSA) voted to reinstate English language proficiency violations as grounds for placing truck drivers out of service. This policy shift, which could significantly impact the nation’s trucking capacity, follows an executive order by President Donald Trump. The order mandates a revision of federal out-of-service criteria, reversing a more lenient policy that had been in place since 2016. During the Obama Administration, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) had eliminated the requirement to remove drivers from service solely due to non-compliance with English Language Proficiency (ELP) standards. The new CVSA rule aims to restore this requirement and will officially take effect on June 25. According to a CVSA press release, “By incorporating English language proficiency into the out-of-service criteria, a commercial motor vehicle inspector may place a driver out of service if they cannot adequately demonstrate their ability to read and speak English.” The FMCSA is expected to provide enforcement guidelines to promote consistent inspections nationwide.

Enforcement Power and Rule Alignment

While the FMCSA is the agency responsible for setting safety regulations for commercial transportation, the CVSA plays a crucial enforcement role. CVSA members include state law enforcement officials, such as highway patrol officers, who have the authority to determine whether violations warrant immediate removal of a driver from service. This development marks a major shift in enforcement, particularly in how English language requirements are treated during inspections. CVSA’s board invoked an emergency clause in its bylaws to pass this measure without the typical voting procedure from Class I Members, citing the 60-day implementation window outlined in President Trump’s executive order.

To ensure regulatory alignment, CVSA also announced its intention to petition the FMCSA to amend 49 CFR 391.11(b)(2). The goal is to officially classify ELP violations as conditions justifying out-of-service designation. Additionally, CVSA wants the English proficiency requirements in 49 CFR Part 383 (which governs CDL issuance) to match those in Part 391 (which governs driver qualifications), thereby promoting uniformity across related regulations.

Potential Impact on Trucking Capacity

The trucking industry may soon feel the ripple effects of this reinstated policy. Insurance analysts estimate that approximately 10% of current CDL holders may not meet federal English proficiency standards. Given that there are more than 3 million interstate CDL holders in the United States, the enforcement of this rule could significantly reduce available driver capacity across the supply chain. This reduction comes at a time when the industry is already grappling with ongoing driver shortages, rising costs, and evolving compliance challenges. For carriers, the new rule means heightened risk in terms of potential service disruptions, particularly if a substantial number of drivers are disqualified during inspections.

Conclusion: Preparing for a New Compliance Reality

The decision by the CVSA to enforce English proficiency as a disqualifying factor for commercial drivers marks a significant change in the regulatory landscape. While the intent is to improve safety through better communication on U.S. roads, the policy may also strain carrier operations and exacerbate driver shortages. With implementation set for June 25, fleets and drivers must prepare now. This includes conducting internal language assessments, offering training resources where needed, and consulting with compliance professionals to understand the implications. As enforcement increases, proactive preparation will be essential to maintaining operational continuity and avoiding costly service disruptions.

Stay Ahead of Compliance Changes in Trucking

As new federal enforcement measures—like the reinstatement of English proficiency violations—take effect, staying compliant isn’t just smart, it’s essential. At Labworks USA, we help truck drivers and fleet operators navigate evolving FMCSA regulations with confidence. Whether you need support with DOT drug and alcohol testing, random selection compliance, or FMCSA Clearinghouse registration, our friendly and knowledgeable DOT Consortium team is here to assist. Let us help you stay on the road—safe, legal, and fully prepared for what’s ahead.

Stay connected with us for the latest insights, regulatory updates, and tools to thrive in today’s trucking and logistics landscape.

Tags: Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance, truck drivers, English proficiency, executive order, Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, English language proficiency, out-of-service criteria, out-of-service violation, Department of Transportation, traffic signs, English language proficiency standards, highway traffic signs, border patrol, commercial vehicle drivers, highway safety, North American Standard Out-of-Service Criteria, Secretary of Transportation, Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association, CDL holders, Commercial Driver's License Standards, Longer Combination Vehicle, CDL drivers, driver qualification issues, driver fatigue, driver population, Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, roadway safety, safety impacts, safety rating, driver-related out-of-service violations, American Trucking Associations, cargo weight-limit station, Electronic Logging Devices, hours-of-service violations, reckless driving violations, driver shortages, interstate CDL drivers, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, English literacy testing, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, federal transportation officials, highway signs, trade associations, Out-of-Service Enforcement Criteria