Myths Debunked and the Role of Freight Demand in Trucking Employment

In the ever-evolving landscape of the trucking industry, misconceptions frequently cloud the understanding of how freight demand influences employment trends. "Myths Debunked and the Role of Freight Demand in Trucking Employment" seeks to clarify the often-overlooked dynamics that govern this vital sector of the economy. Many believe that a high demand for freight automatically translates to increased job opportunities for truck drivers, yet the relationship is far more complex. Factors such as technological advancements, regulatory changes, and shifts in consumer behavior all play pivotal roles in shaping employment patterns within the industry. Additionally, persistent myths regarding driver shortages and job security often perpetuate misunderstanding among those considering a career in trucking.

By examining these myths and providing data-driven insights into freight demand trends, this article aims to illuminate how market fluctuations influence employment rates and job stability in trucking. Understanding these intricacies is crucial not only for prospective drivers and industry stakeholders but also for policymakers and economic analysts who seek to navigate the challenges and opportunities within this crucial sector. Through thoughtful examination and informed discussion, we can foster a more accurate perception of the trucking industry and its labor market, paving the way for informed decisions and sustainable growth.

Rethinking the Truck Driver Shortage Narrative

The ongoing discourse regarding the "driver shortage" in the trucking sector has been a topic of contention for several decades. The American Trucking Associations (ATA) has asserted the existence of a persistent driver deficit since 1987, referencing nine separate studies to support its claims. However, researchers and industry specialists contend that the labor market adapts effectively to fluctuations in freight demand. A recent study conducted by Professors Jonathan Phares, Jason Miller, and Stephen Burks, and published by the Association for Supply Chain Management in December 2024, illustrates that trucking companies hire drivers in response to increased freight demand and scale back their workforce when demand wanes.

Carriers typically exhibit a rational response to market demands. An upturn in freight requirements stimulates hiring, often accompanied by competitive wages to attract drivers. Conversely, a downturn leads to workforce reductions. The ongoing narrative of a driver shortage, largely propagated by ATA-endorsed studies, overlooks the complexity of freight demand dynamics and the adaptability of the labor market.

The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted this relationship in a dramatic way. From March to April 2020, trucking employment experienced the largest single-month decline on record, with 84,500 jobs (5.6%) lost. This disruption underscored the critical role that freight demand plays in shaping employment trends, as recovery from May 2020 to December 2021 was driven by seven key freight-related factors.

The Role of Freight Demand in Employment Trends

The study identifies several major factors behind the ebb and flow of trucking employment. Natural resource extraction plays a significant role, with activities such as fracking and mining generating substantial freight volume. For instance, a single fracking well requires over 1,145 heavy truck trips for materials. The collapse in oil prices during 2020 led to a 41% reduction in drilling and a 10% decrease in mining. This, in turn, resulted in an 18% and 15% drop in trucking jobs in North Dakota and Wyoming by 2021, respectively. When demand slowed, specialized trucks could not be easily repurposed, creating regional employment challenges.

The growth of warehousing, particularly due to the e-commerce boom, also significantly impacted trucking. Warehousing jobs rose 14% in 2020 and surged another 38% in 2021, especially in states like California and Arizona. This expansion supported an 8% increase in trucking payrolls, as demand for drayage and local freight grew alongside warehousing needs.

Container ports were another driver of freight demand. A 17% increase in retail imports at major U.S. ports in 2021 boosted employment in drayage and transloading sectors. The sheer volume of freight flowing through ports provided carriers with opportunities to expand hiring, with minimal labor competition from port operations themselves.

How Supporting Sectors Drive Freight Needs

Construction, wholesaling, and courier services also played critical roles in creating freight opportunities without directly competing for drivers. In Florida, a 2.6% growth in construction in 2021 corresponded with an 11.8% increase in trucking jobs, as materials required transportation. Wholesaling and courier services, closely linked to e-commerce, generated consistent freight demands while employing different labor pools than truck drivers.

Manufacturing continues to be the backbone of freight demand, responsible for 60% of for-hire trucking ton-miles. Michigan’s auto sector recovery in 2021 spurred growth in nearby states such as Ohio, as carriers scrambled to meet transportation needs. Similarly, the retail and consumer goods sector surged, with imports rising 17% in 2021. This placed additional pressure on carriers to meet demand, particularly in states like Florida where distribution activity increased substantially.

Energy and broader economic influences also shaped freight volumes. Refining and petrochemical freight fell in 2020, slowing job growth. However, seasonal retail demand and a rebound in oil prices in 2021 spurred additional hiring, showing how cyclical freight needs directly influence labor adjustments.

Construction and Trucking: A Complementary Relationship

A key insight from the study is that construction does not compete directly with trucking for labor, contrary to common assumptions. Instead, construction activity stimulates freight demand, creating more trucking jobs. For example, Florida’s 2.6% increase in construction jobs from 2019 to 2021 coincided with an 11.8% rise in trucking employment. This connection demonstrates that construction helps support trucking employment rather than diminishing the driver pool.

The skill sets required in construction—such as carpentry, masonry, or electrical work—do not overlap with truck driving. This distinction reduces labor competition between the two industries. Additionally, freight associated with construction projects typically relies on standard trucks rather than specialized vehicles, making it easier for carriers to meet demand without losing drivers to construction roles.

This complementary relationship challenges the long-standing belief that trucking and construction are in competition. Instead, both industries benefit from the other, reinforcing the idea that freight demand is the central driver of trucking employment trends.

Labor Market Dynamics and Wage Competition

The trucking industry operates in cycles of expansion and contraction, reflecting the strength of freight demand. During periods of growth in manufacturing or retail, carriers actively recruit drivers, often raising wages to attract talent. Emerging firms are particularly aggressive during these surges, though they may downsize quickly once freight volumes decline.

The rise of e-commerce and port-related freight has created jobs with minimal overlap with other industries, further reducing the perception of a driver shortage. Courier services, for example, support freight needs but do not require CDL-certified drivers, while port operations complement trucking without directly competing for workers.

Ultimately, the so-called “driver shortage” is better understood as a natural labor market adjustment to the cyclical nature of freight demand. Competitive wages and hiring surges occur when freight is plentiful, while contractions follow downturns. This ebb and flow ensures that the labor market continues to adapt effectively to the needs of the industry.

Strategic Implications for Industry and Policy

The findings carry important implications for both industry leaders and policymakers. Regulatory focus should shift from addressing supposed driver shortages to strengthening freight demand itself. By investing in and supporting freight-generating sectors such as e-commerce, manufacturing, ports, and retail, policymakers can ensure sustained trucking employment growth.

Carriers must also prepare for seasonal surges in freight, particularly during holiday retail peaks or oil market fluctuations. Effective workforce planning during these high-demand periods can reduce volatility in employment while supporting supply chain resilience. Regions dependent on resource extraction may face more hiring challenges during downturns, making diversification into other freight sectors essential for stability.

Instead of pursuing initiatives like lowering the driver age threshold or creating new labor-entry programs, efforts should prioritize policies that sustain freight demand and improve logistics efficiency. By aligning industry strategies with freight trends, trucking employment can remain stable and resilient.

Conclusion: Freight Demand, Not Driver Supply, Shapes Trucking Employment

The evidence challenges the prevailing narrative of a truck driver shortage. States with strong warehousing, port infrastructure, manufacturing, and retail activity saw substantial job growth after the COVID-19 downturn, while regions reliant on resource extraction faced significant hiring barriers. Construction, often thought to compete with trucking, instead drives freight needs and supports trucking employment.

Ultimately, trucking employment is not constrained by a lack of drivers but by the level of freight demand. When freight volumes rise, carriers hire; when demand falls, they reduce staff. This cycle reflects a responsive labor market that adapts to economic conditions. Recognizing freight demand as the central factor reshapes how policymakers and industry leaders should approach workforce planning and regulation, moving away from the “driver shortage” myth and toward strategies that strengthen the freight economy.

Stay Informed and Stay Compliant

The trucking industry’s employment outlook is shaped less by a so-called “driver shortage” and more by freight demand across key sectors like e-commerce, manufacturing, and ports. Staying informed about these trends helps drivers, carriers, and stakeholders better prepare for shifts in opportunity and compliance.

At Labworks USA, we not only provide updates on the latest trucking, freight, and logistics insights, but we also help drivers stay compliant with DOT drug and alcohol testing requirements. Our friendly DOT Consortium team is ready to guide you through random testing programs and FMCSA Clearinghouse registration, so you can focus on seizing new opportunities as freight demand grows.

Tags: truck drivers, trucking industry, supply chain, driver shortage, Trucking Jobs, Truck Driving, professional truck driver, truck driver shortage, freight demand, American Trucking Associations, freight volumes, Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, hours of service, COVID-19 pandemic, truck stops, truck driving jobs, supply and demand, Supply Chain Management, National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, Department of Transportation, transportation industry, freight recession, freight rates, freight factoring, freight carrier, freight capacity, electric trucks, Heavy Truck Trips, flatbed trucking, trucking communities, Anderson Trucking Service, trucking businesses, safety features, safety standards, driver retention, transportation management system, autonomous semi-trucks, freight brokers, BMC-84 freight broker surety bond, freight marketplace, freight planning, freight transportation, Future of Freight Festival, Patriot Freight Group, refrigerated freight, specialty freight carriers, truckload motor freight, American Truck Training, self-driving trucks, truck driving career, truck driving lifestyle, autonomous trucks, garbage trucks, truck counts, truck terminals, average trucking salary, digital trucking services, for-hire trucking sector, local and regional trucking, long-distance trucking, trucking apps, load counts, load volumes, dry van loads, full trailer loads, safety initiatives, safety regulations, commercial driver's licenses, truck automation